Until Dawn released at the right time for me.
Back in 2015 I was a teenager obsessed with horror movies and choose-your-own-adventure video games.
Naturally, when I saw advertisements for a horror video game where your choices determine which characters live and die, I was completley on board.
I was a day-one Until Dawn player and it certainly did not disappoint.
I have replayed the game many times over the years and, with only a few months until Until Dawn 2 releases, along with the tragic news of the game’s star Hayden Panettiere passing away, I decided to jump into the story again and drop a review once I finished.
One year after a cruel prank resulted in the disappearance of two sisters, eight of their friends return to Blackwood Pines, the mountain where the twins vanished.
However, what is planned to be a fun night of partying quickly turns into a life-or-death struggle, as the group is stalked by a deranged psycho, hellbent on revenge.

To get into what makes Until Dawn’s story so excellent, I have to spoil it, so if you have somehow not played this over a decade-old game I would recommend doing so before continuing.
In my opinion, Until Dawn had some of the greatest marketing in video game history.
It sold the game as a choose-your-own-adventure slasher film, where a masked, psychopathic killer is the main threat.
Yet, as you go through the story and discover clues to the mystery, something just feels off about the situation.
So, when the game pulls the rug out from under you, revealing the supposed psycho is actually a revenge prank and the true threat are the Wendigos, cannibalistic monsters from Native American folklore, it feels so natural.

What makes it better is that nowhere in the game’s advertisements were the Wendigo’s hinted at, making the slow reveal of what is hunting the friends worth the wait.
Speaking of these friends, Until Dawn’s characters are great, whether you are supposed to like them or not.
There is Sam (Panettiere), who fits into the role of final girl, a well-known trope in horror films.
Then there is Josh, the grieving and severely mentally ill brother of the missing sisters, who aims to sadistically terrorize his friends as revenge for their disappearance.
Rami Malek gives the best performance of the game as this damaged individual.

One thing that I really appreciate the characters of Until Dawn is that, when the horror starts, some of them actually leap away from the tropes they have been presented as.
The perfect example of this is Mike (Brett Dalton), one of the main instigators of the original prank.
In the game’s opening hours, he is presented as a womanizing jerk, someone who is popular in school but would immediately turn coward in a life or death situation, making the audience cheer for the karma of his death.
However, when the ball gets rolling, and Jessica is taken, Mike immediately jumps into action, defying the tropes and becoming one of the game’s heroes, alongside Sam.
Despite that, Mike still maintains parts of his flawed personality, making for one of the most complicated and compelling characters in the game.

The top-notch writing for these characters make the life or death choices you have to make for them, even more intense.
As was advertised, everyone can survive the night, everyone can die, and everything in between, based on your choices.
On my first playthrough, only Sam, Chris and Jessica survived.
However, it is not just your decisions that determine who survives.
There are often quick-time events and the unique don’t move mechanic, where you have to keep your controller completely still if you don’t want to see a character meet their gruesome demise.
At first, this just feels like a neat gimmick, until it is revealed the Wendigo’s rely on Jurassic Park rules, with their vision being based on movement.
If you want to save everyone in your playthrough, you will have to master not moving your controller (or, you know, just sit it down but that removes all tension).
This results in one of the most intense scenes in gaming history, with Sam having to consistently hide and remain still around the lodge to give all of her friends time to escape the Wendigos.

However, this terror would not exist without the aid of the game’s cinematography, soundtrack, and graphics.
Much like the original Resident Evil, Until Dawn is played from a fixed camera angle and the cinematographers clearly had a lot of fun designing these areas, using the position of the shots to elevate the horror, like when Emily discover’s Beth’s head in the mines.
Then there is the soundtrack by Jason Graves, which is just iconic.
So many of Until Dawn’s themes remain stuck in my head to this day, most notably “Lodge Finale” and the incredible “O Death” rendition by Jeff Grace and Amy Van Roekel.
Finally, there are the graphics, which were impressive back in 2015 and remain solid now in 2026.
This made it all the more confusing when there was a remake released in 2024.
Sure, the graphics were improved but, in my opinion, the remake removed a lot of what made the original Until Dawn special, notably the fixed camera angles and especially the soundtrack.
The new tracks just do not feel suitable for what is happening in-game, the soundtrack played during the credits drowns out the characters’ voices, and they even removed “O Death.”

I will always recommend the original over the remake because it feels much truer to the game’s original vision.
That being said, the remake did make some worthy changes.
It removed the annoying “Previously on Until Dawn” segments, extended the opening scene, gave players the chance to actually save Josh, and added a post-credits scene with Sam, which we now know is teasing Until Dawn 2.
Speaking of that scene, I do hope this means Hayden Panettiere will have a role to play in the upcoming sequel, or at least a cameo.
Maybe she filmed scenes for the game before her tragic passing?
Even if she did not, I hope the game at least pays tribute to her because, whenever I think of Hayden Panettiere, her role as Sam in Until Dawn is always what first comes to mind.

Back to the game itself, even though I love Until Dawn, I still cannot say it is perfect.
There are a few visual glitches here and there, Sam and Mike have pretty serious plot armour until the final chapter, and a couple of choices do seem pretty pointless in retrospect.
But the story, characters, cinematography and soundtrack are all still fantastic and, even though I know the narrative by heart because of so many playthroughs, I still find ways to make replays enjoyable, like flipping a coin to make decisions in my latest run.
Hopefully, the upcoming sequel can live up to the legacy of this classic.
To build up my excitement for it, I plan to play through all of the choice-based Supermassive games and, once I’ve played Until Dawn 2 a few times, I will rank it alongside them.
Until then, know that Until Dawn is one of the best choice based video games out there.
